We adopted a rescue in October and started dog training at our local pet food store right away. These treats are awesome! The dog loves them, they smell (our vet says the smellier the better, makes them want to eat it more), even the cats love these too! they are the perfect size for training, small enough that you aren’t blowing through treats super fast and are just giving them enough to want to do what you are asking them to do for the reward. These are super clean being made of just one thing, organic beef liver, that’s it. For the size bag and for these being organic these are a good value and I would definitely buy these again.